Church Pays $1.5 Million to Leave PC(USA)

This week’s Ministry Briefing has more than a few stories about denominational struggles, here is one:

First Presbyterian Church of San Antonio, a megachurch formerly in the PC USA, has paid $1.5 million to their former denomination in order to join the Evangelical Covenant Order of Presbyterians. The church cited theological differences with the PC USA and noted that it had a strong legal position but ruled it was better to settle the matter financially rather than fight a legal battle.

Source: Christian Times

Why does this matter for church leaders?

Denominations and individual congregations are more likely than ever to fragment over theological issues. This story suggests several key points for church leaders to consider:

  • How will you handle controversial issues? There’s a good chance that your congregation and denomination are filled with people who disagree on a wide range of theological issues.
  • How do you decide which issues are primary and which are secondary? When divisions emerge, do you have a process in place for discussion and reconciliation?
  • What do your governing documents say about leaving a denomination or splitting a church? While no one wants to think about a church dividing or a congregation leaving a denomination, leaders should review their guidelines and by-laws in order to determine the best course forward when there are divisions.

Lawsuits are a last resort. This story reveals the wisdom of two groups opting to reach a settlement that avoids a long, costly court battle and make it possible for both groups to return to their ministry work.

What would it take for YOU to consider leaving a denomination?

Ministry Briefing helps church leaders save time and lead betterMinistry Briefing subscribers receive a weekly curated list of the 40 most important church-related stories of the week, summarized with the original link (like what you see above). We keep church leaders abreast of cultural trends, stocked with new sermon illustrations, and save them time so they can focus on what really matters. 

Readers of my blog can get their first month for $1 by clicking here.


About the Author: Matt Steen

I love Jesus, Theresa (my wife), the Redskins & Capitals, and am currently living in Waco, Texas where I am studying the finer points of BBQ (while working on my MDiv and MBA at Baylor University). When not studying, I serve church leaders through MinistryBriefing.com and am the Director of Connections for Harris Creek Baptist Church's Downtown Campus.